A Sudden, Fearful Death

He looked around curiously as he always did. One could learn much from the observation of people's homes, not merely their financial situations but their tastes, a guess at their educations, whether they had traveled or not, sometimes even their beliefs and prejudices and what they wished others to think of them. In the case of family homes of more than one generation, one could also learn something of parents, and thus of upbringing.

The Barrymores' hallway did not offer a great deal. The house was quite large, but of a cottage style, low-windowed, low-ceilinged, with oak beams across. It had apparently been designed for the comfort of a large family, rather than to entertain guests or to impress. The hall was wooden-floored, pleasant; two or three chintz-covered chairs sat against the walls, but there were no bookcases, no portraits or samplers from which to judge the taste of the occupants, and the single hat stand was not of particular character and boasted no walking stick, and only one rather well worn umbrella.

The maid returned, still looking very subdued.

"If you will come this way, sir, Mr. Barrymore will see you in the study."

Obediently he followed her across the hall and down a narrow passage toward the rear of the house, where a surprisingly pleasant room opened onto the back garden. Through French doors he saw a closely clipped lawn shaded at the end by willows leaning over the water. There were few flowers, but instead delicate shrubs with a wonderful variety of foliage.

Mr. Barrymore was a tall, lean man with a mobile face full of imagination. Monk could see that the man in front of him had lost not only a child, but some part of himself. Monk felt guilty for intruding. What did law, or even justice, matter in the face of this grief? No solution, no due process or punishment, would bring her back or alter what had happened. What on earth use was revenge?

"Good morning, sir," Barrymore said soberly. The marks of distress were plain in his face, and he did not apologize for them or make useless attempts at disguise. He looked at Monk uncertainly. "My maid said you had called with regard to our daughter's death. She did not mention the police, but do I assume that that is who you are? She mentioned a Lady Daviot, but that must have been a misunderstanding. We know no one of that name."

Monk wished he had some art or gift to soften what must be said, but he knew of none. Perhaps simple truth was the best. Prevarication would lengthen it to no purpose.

"No, Mr. Barrymore, I used to be in the police, but I left the force. Now I work privately." He loathed saying that. It sounded grubby, as if he chased sneak thieves and errant wives. "Lady Callandra Daviot"-that sounded better-"is a member of the Board of Governors of the hospital, and had a deep regard for Miss Barrymore. She is concerned in case the police do not learn all the facts of the case, or do not pursue it thoroughly, should it lead to troubling any authorities or persons of consequence. Therefore she asked me, as a personal favor to her, if I would pursue the matter myself."

A wan smile flickered over Barrymore's face and vanished again.

"Does it not concern you to disturb important people, Mr. Monk? I would have thought you more vulnerable to disfavor than the police. One assumes they have the force of government to back them."

"That rather depends on who the important people are," Monk pointed out.

Barrymore frowned. They were still standing in the middle of the charming room with the garden beyond. It did not seem an occasion to sit.

"Surely you cannot suspect anyone of that nature to be involved in Prudence's death." Barrymore said the last word as if he still found it difficult to grasp, and none of the first agonizing pain had yet dulled.

"I have no idea," Monk replied. "But it is very usual for a murder investigation to uncover a great many other events and relationships which people would prefer to have kept secret. Sometimes they will go to considerable lengths to see that they remain so, even if it means concealing the real crime."

"And you imagine you will be able to learn something that the police will not?" Barrymore asked. He was still courteous but his disbelief was undeniable.

"I don't know, but I shall try. I have in the past succeeded where they have failed."

"Have you?" It was not a challenge, not even a question, merely a noting of fact. "What can we tell you? I know nothing of the hospital at all." He stared out of the window at the sunlight on the leaves. "Indeed, I know very little of the practice of medicine. I am a collector of rare butterflies, myself. Something of an authority on the subject." He smiled sadly, looking back at Monk. "It all seems rather pointless now, doesn't it?"

"No," Monk said quietly. 'The study of what is beautiful can never be wasted, especially if you are seeking to understand and preserve it."