Cat in a Jeweled Jumpsuit

Elvis' life and death is an object lesson in the perils of peaking early. Before he was eighteen, he experienced two intensely emotional elements in his life that nothing else could ever duplicate: a singular connection to his mother, an extended and symbiotic twinship, and the artistic and erotic euphoria of a performing charisma that drove his audiences to frenzy. His mother died when he was twenty-three. Nine years of movie-making surgically separated him from his live audiences. Fame and fortune forced him into isolation from overwhelming fan adulation and death threats. Nine years of a return to the manic-depressive performer's emotional seesaw brought him from career rebirth and comeback triumph to a drug-assisted decline and death.

Compare how Elvis and Marilyn were alike: Both were self-made blue-collar heroes Both stuttered Both scorned underwear Both had birth certificate misspellings of their middle names (Norma Jeane/Jean; Elvis Aron/Aaron) Both were overmedicated by doctors Both created iconic personas that were perpetuated by impersonators and massive merchandising Both rebelled against the sexual hypocrisy of the fifties Both sought to be taken "seriously" as actors; Marilyn fought for and got better films Both were dominated by soulless money men who stifled their potential and careers

The best book about Elvis is Peter Guralnick's two-volume biography. The Last Train to Memphis relates Elvis's phenomenal rise up till 1958, when his mother died and the draft interrupted his career, sending him to Germany as an army private. John Lennon later said that Elvis died when he went to Germany. Careless Love is subtitled "The Unmaking of Elvis Presley" and covers the twenty-year period after Elvis returned to the United States until his shocking death at the age of forty-two.

Guralnick's books cite the few useful parts of the many memoirs that focus on Elvis's failings and extreme behaviors, and also convey the inborn personal charm and the performance charisma that Elvis cultivated shrewdly before the sheer weight of his popularity (andtherefore power) overcame even his remarkable gifts. The Inner Elvis by Peter Whitmer, Ph.D., explores the pathology of a surviving twin and identifies Elvis as an abused child whose "lethal enmeshment" by a doting and domineering parent, his mother Gladys, doomed him to the fate he found. P. F. Kluge's novel, Biggest Elvis, about Elvis impersonators in Guam, is moving and insightful. Gilbert B. Rodman's Elvis After Elvis makes a scholarly case for Elvis single-handedly creating the climate for the sixties' social revolution: youth culture, the protest movement for civil rights and against Vietnam, the sexual revolution and gay rights, and ultimately, the resurgence of feminism that resulted from all the preceding.

Reading many of the dozens of books about a pop icon like Elvis is like listening to conflicting yet buttressing testimony from an endless parade of witnesses in a legal case. You must strain fact from self-serving faction. You read details about the prescription medication dosages, the autopsy, and the theoretical causes of death; you consider forensic psychology and testimony of interested and disinterested parties. You eventually distill the flood of facts and opinions into a theory of your own.

Here's mine: both nature and nurture created and destroyed Elvis Presley. His extended family of aunts, uncles, and cousins had what is now recognized as a genetic disposition to the disease of alcoholism. His mother was never autopsied, and her death at age forty-six was attributed to liver disease, but it is thought to have been cirrhosis of the liver. She certainly drank in her last years. The headstone Elvis put on her grave reads "She was the Sunshine of our Home," and during Elvis's youth she was described as musical and fun-loving, although possessed of a frying-pan-throwing temperament. Photos of Elvis with his parents as his fame grew show a somber, tender symbiosis: Elvis and Gladys always focusing on and touching each other; Vernon a tangential figure on the fringe of this consuming bond. But Gladys's eyes are ringed with unhealthy black, her expression is dead (or dazed by alcohol). She is not a well or happy woman. Her cherished son's meteoric rise, her loss of contact and control as he was swept away in a fever of touring and publicity and screaming girl groupies, coincided with her decline and death.