I said, "You're lying."
"Did you tell yourself it wasn't yours?" said So'enel. "I assure you that it was."
"Shut up."
"And that child grew into a woman, who had a child of her own."
"I said shut up."
But he didn't shut up. "A child that grew up strong and sweet and brave and beautiful, so like your fair Elizabeth."
"Shut up shut up shut up!"
"A child that this one killed, without mercy, and without remorse."
My entire body shook in rage and pain and sudden doubt. I looked from the seraph to Kate, who once more fought against her restraints. She was trying in vain to speak, but the gag prevented it, deadening her words into a frantic series of grunts. Her eyes, wide with shock and terror, found mine, and even without her words to guide me, I knew that she was beseeching me not to listen.
"It seems the girl has something she'd like to say," the angel said. "Well, then, by all means, let her speak." He gestured, and the duct tape unwound from Kate's mouth as if of its own accord. "But first, my dear, a question. Your half-brother: what was his name?"
Kate forgot her fear for a moment, so thrown was she by the question. "C-c-connor," she said. "Connor MacNeil."
"Yes," said So'enel, not unkindly, "but what was his
At that last, Kate's eyes went wide with shock and horror. When she spoke, it was flat, uninflected, barely audible. To me, though, it was a fucking knife in the gut.
"Samuel," she said. A single tear tracked downward across her trembling cheek. Then, as if from somewhere far away: "Patricia said it was in honor of her grandfather. But Sam, I never thought–"
"Enough of this," the angel said. "You see, Collector, I've steered you true. You know what it is you have to do."
I felt sick. Tears poured down my face, and my breath came in ragged, hitching gasps.
"Collector," So'enel said, and then he stopped short, correcting himself. "
"No!" I said, clenching shut my eyes as though to shut out the world – as though to shut out the angel's words.