In the Bleak Midwinter

A mid-week drive up to Cossayaharie usually relaxed Russ. Although Millers Kill policed the rural township, he seldom patrolled the mountain roads and tiny village himself. So his associations with the area were mostly good ones: visits to his sister’s farm, fishing up at the lake, hiking into the hills, or picnicking in the Muster Field, where militiamen had gathered during the French and Indian War and the Revolution after that. Returning from Cossayaharie you could drive through almost every war the men from this area had taken part in. There were the crumbling granite stones in the Muster Field, and then a big marble obelisk at the front of the old Cossayaharie cemetery, a memorial for two brothers who had drowned in the War of 1812. Before you reached Millers Kill, you passed by its cemetery, guarded by a droopy-mustached Union soldier holding a rifle and forever looking South to where his fallen brothers lay. Then over the bridge, stone cairns carrying brass plaques dedicating it to the sacred memory of those who fell in the Great War, and on into town, where a four-sided plinth listed the names of those who had served in each branch of the armed forces during World War Two. If you finished your journey at the post office, you could run your fingers over the bronze plaque memorializing men who had died on the Korean peninsula while he had been in diapers.

There was nothing marking his war. He didn’t know how he felt about that, and he didn’t want to think about it long enough to make up his mind one way or the other. There had been what his mother described as one almighty patriotic hot flash over Desert Storm, and since then, there had been talk on and off of putting up something for the rest of the veterans. He stayed away from it. He didn’t want to become one of those big-bellied guys down at the American Legion, droning on about their war adventures as if they had forgotten what it was really like. Probably file clerks and car-pool mechanics, anyway. The ones who knew what it was really like hardly ever talked about it, not in the Legion Hall bar and not in front of some committee to erect a monument.

He passed the obelisk to the brothers who had died in the waters of Lake Erie and took the next right turn. A dense stand of spruce and hemlock crowded in on either side of the road. As it wound its way into the hills, the evergreens petered out and the scenery opened up onto sprawling, uneven grazing fields bordered by bare-branched hardwoods. The road dipped and twisted, past sheltered hayfields, farmhouses, and an occasional trailer. For a mile or so, a stony creek ran alongside the road, black water barely visible under the heavy banks of snow. He drove past sleeping orchards of dwarf apple trees, modern feed silos, and century-old barns. At Jock Montgomery’s place, he saw two of the kids making a snowman in the front yard, and he slowed down, tooted, and waved.

The Stoner’s farm was a mile past the Montgomerys’. He crunched into the drive, parking next to Mindy’s Chevelle. He was relieved to see Ethan’s old pickup by the road leading up the hill toward the cow barn.

Mindy Stoner came out on the porch, wiping her hands on a dishcloth. “Russ,” she said. “What brings you up this way?” She was a tall, raw-boned woman, whose square, strong features had looked almost homely back when she was a schoolgirl. Time had refined her so that now, in her forties, she had the spare beauty of a mountaintop blown clean of snow.

He held up the folded paper. “I’m afraid I’m here on business, Mindy. Can I come in?”

She looked back toward the kitchen, then opened the door. “You might as well. No need to freeze out here in the door-yard.” Russ scraped the slush off his boots and followed her through the mudroom into the kitchen, a large room of wooden cupboards, blue-and-white dish towel fabrics, and children’s papers and artwork tacked up everywhere. The woodstove between the mudroom and the pantry was throwing off heat, and the overhead lamp had been lit in preparation for the four o’clock twilight. Their thirteen-year-old—her name escaped him for the moment—was sitting at the round, oilcloth-covered table, doing homework. “Hannah,” Mindy said, “run up to the barn and tell your father Chief Van Alstyne’s here and needs to speak with him.”

The girl gaped, her too-large eyes widening with a mix of excitement and apprehension. “Is Daddy in trouble?”

Russ shook his head. “No. But I am going to have to speak with Ethan, too.”

“He’s out in the barn with Wayne, hooking up for the milking. Hannah, fetch ’em both in.”

At the mention of her brother’s name, the girl had relaxed. “Oh, Ethan,” she said, heading for the mudroom. “That figures.”

Her mother sighed. “What’s he gone and done now, Russ?”

He laid the papers on the kitchen table. “Have you heard about the girl found murdered by the kill last week?”