PART I
DAMNING EVIDENCE
1
SUMMER SLOWLY DECLINED AS IF IN THE GRIP OF A wasting disease, then the orange flare of autumn swept by in the blink of an eye, leaving the western Catskill Mountains a dull brown. November arrived with a windy chill that never let up and a long succession of shortening days that passed with no sign of the sun.
On a raw, gusty afternoon Dave and Madeleine Gurney were hard at work outside their farmhouse, high in the hills outside the village of Walnut Crossing. Autumn leaves skittered across the patio they were reshaping. Dave eased an unwieldy slab of bluestone into its new position. Still lean and strong in his early fifties, he welcomed the exercise.
Madeleine carefully set down a wheelbarrow full of fresh sod next to him. “Did you call your son?”
He blinked. “What?”
“Today is his birthday.”
“Oh. Yes. Right. I’ll give him a call after dinner.”
For the past week, they’d been changing the contours of the old stone patio that lay between the house and the chicken coop. The previous spring’s Harrow Hill murder case had reached its bloody conclusion on this patio, and the intervening months had done so little to free Madeleine from the images of that dreadful night that she still found it a challenge to step out through the French doors. The work they were engaged in was an attempt to alter the look of the place in the hope of diluting the memory of what occurred there. Gurney hoped it might also dissipate the hard-to-define strain present in her expression more often than not these days.
The project was almost finished. He had completed most of the stonework and had broken up the hard Catskill earth for new planting beds. Madeleine had painted the chicken coop and its attached shed a cheerful yellow and planted dozens of tulip bulbs around the reconfigured patio.
As he leaned on his crowbar to adjust the position of the final slab of bluestone, the wind rose, and the first flakes of a promised snow shower swirled around him.
“I think we’ve done enough for today,” said Madeleine, glancing at the slaty sky. “Besides, Emma should be arriving anytime now.” She looked at him. “David, you’re scowling.”
“Maybe because you seem to know more about her visit than you’re telling me.”
“All I know is, she wants to talk to you about a murder case.”
He laid his crowbar next to the wheelbarrow and took off his work gloves. “I doubt she’s coming here just to talk.”
Madeleine turned her strained face away from a gust of wind, started toward the French doors, and froze with a sharp little cry.
Gurney stepped quickly over to her. “What is it?”
She pointed at a spot on the ground just beyond the edge of the patio. He followed her terrified gaze.
“The leaves moved. A snake!”
Gurney approached the spot, his shovel at the ready. When he was within striking distance, a small gray creature darted from the leaves and disappeared under a nearby shrub.
“No snake,” said Gurney. “Just a vole.”
Madeleine breathed a shaky sigh of relief.
He was tempted to remind her that there were no snakes to be concerned about in their part of the Catskills. But he knew it would make no difference.
2
GURNEY STOOD WITH HIS BACK TO THE SHOWERHEAD. The warm, tingling spray massaged his neck and shoulders, gradually releasing the muscle tightness caused by hefting the patio stones, as well as the emotional tension of recalling what had happened on the patio six months earlier.