Tigerheart and Tawny pelt looked at each other, uneasy acceptance flashing in their eyes, and then slowly backed away.
What was wrong with the others? Violetpaw stared at them in disbelief. Did they truly all want a rogue leader instead of Rowanstar?
She glanced at Rowanstar as he staggered to his paws. Blood welled on his m uzzle and darkened his neck fur. As he backed toward Dawnpelt, Violetpaw could see that he was trem bling.
Dawnpelt pressed against his flank to steady him. Tigerheart and Tawny pelt j oined them, bunching close together like cornered m ice.
Violetpaw blinked at the huddled group of her Clanmates, feeling sick. “What do we do?” she breathed, one eye on the rogues.
Rowanstar looked at her, pain showing in his eyes. “We go to the Gathering.” He padded forward, lifting his chin. Tigerheart and Tawny pelt followed. Violetpaw started after them, Dawnpelt at her side.
Spikefur curled his lip. “If you go,” he rem inded the ShadowClan leader, “don’t come back.”
“Puddleshine!” Rowanstar beckoned to the medicine cat with a flick of his tail. “Come with us.”
Puddleshine hurried after him.
“Wait.” Spikefur blocked his son’s path. “You can’t leave. Your Clan needs y ou.”
Puddleshine halted, his pelt ruffling. He glanced toward the den where the sick cats lay, then around at his Clanmates and the rogues.
Spikefur went on. “ShadowClan can’t be without a medicine cat again. What if Pinenose relapses? Would you ever forgive y ourself if y our mother died because you left?” He leaned closer to Puddleshine. “If
Puddleshine’s eyes glittered with uncertainty.
Rowanstar paused and looked at the young medicine cat. “I will understand if you decide to stay,” he meowed grim ly.
Puddleshine dropped his gaze. “I can’t leave,” he m urm ured. “I have sworn to protect my Clanmates.”
As he turned and retreated to the medicine cat den, Sleekwhisker padded forward and fixed her gaze on Dawnpelt. “Didn’t you miss m e and Juniperclaw?”
Violetpaw felt Dawnpelt stiffen beside her, but her m entor could hardly m eet her kit’s gaze.
“You betrayed your Clan,” she mumbled.
“But we’ve come to help them. And you.” Sleekwhisker’s eyes glittered in the moonlight.
“Now that Crowfrost is dead, we’re all you have.”
Dawnpelt puffed out her chest. “I still have Strikestone.” But as she glanced at the young tom, he backed away. “Are you staying?” She sounded like she could hardly believe it.
“Where else can I go?” Strikestone m urm ured. “Where can
Dawnpelt hesitated.
“You can’t stay!” Violetpaw stared at her desperately, but she could see resignation in her m entor’s gaze.
“He’s right,” Dawnpelt whispered. “I can’t leave every single one of m y kits. And this is the only home I’ve known. How can I leave?” She blinked apologetically at Rowanstar, her father, and then Tawny pelt and Tigerheart.
The ShadowClan leader turned away, dism ay darkening his eyes. Lifting his tail, he barged between the rogues and ducked through the tunnel. Tigerheart and Tawny pelt followed him, their pelts spiking.
Violetpaw glanced at Needletail, who was watching Rowanstar’s retreat with satisfaction.
Needletail always questioned all the rules of the Clan? It was what had always scared Violetpaw about her—and thrilled her.
Violetpaw tore her eyes from Needletail and headed after her Clanmates.
“Wait!” Needletail’s mew sounded in her ear as she passed. The silver she-cat’s scent washed over her. “Where are you going? I thought y ou’d stay. Please don’t leave m e again!”
Violetpaw m et Needletail’s pleading gaze. Even as her paws tingled with eagerness to leave, the fact that Needletail wanted her to stay warm ed a place deep inside her. “You don’t need m e.
You have plenty of friends here.” Her gaze flashed to Rain. “And you have him.”
“But they’re not m y kin, not like you are.” Needletail stared at her anxiously.
“Please stay,” Needletail begged. “We can make ShadowClan the Clan it used to be, before y ou cam e. A great Clan. A brave Clan. You’ll be proud to be part of it.” She looked around the rogues. “These are cats who understand what it’s like not to belong. They will be as loy al to you as I have been. We’re like kin now. Can you say that about any other cat y ou’ve known?”
Grief clawed at Violetpaw’s heart as she remembered how ThunderClan had let Rowanstar take her from her sister without lifting a paw to stop him, and how Twigpaw had walked away from her to return to her Clanmates. Needletail was right. She was the closest thing Violetpaw had ever known to
She blinked at Needletail. “Okay,” she mewed. “I’ll stay.”